
Once upon a time, I went to work with an eye so black it was bright purple. A complete ring of bruise. I told all who asked my plausible story about how I was injured at my second job.
We all went to the break room at lunch and sat around the plywood table, the chattier women talking non-stop as usual. As I sat there, quiet as usual, not one of the women addressed me. Instead, they talked about me and around me. They made their declarations for the entire break….
“If my man ever hit me, I’d kick his ass."
“There’s no way a man would EVER hit me more than once”
“If a woman doesn’t leave, maybe she’s asking for it”
No one spoke to me directly. No one asked my opinion about any of it. They spoke loudly for all the room to hear, including the other tables filled with men and women.
The shame and judgement I felt at that moment was far greater than any split lip, black eye, or broken bone I had been at risk of receiving. Any thought I had of asking for help, was extinguished in those 20 minutes.
Years later, I had become independent, educated, and professional. A helping professional in the “helping profession.” I observed a battered woman being helped. It was unsafe for her to return home, according to staff. She was exhausted and wanted her home, her clothes, her things. She desperately wanted a shower, she said repeatedly. She would have left on her own, but she didn’t have transportation and it was too far to walk. Staff happily helped her find a shower in the old area of the building. They provided soap, shampoo, a towel, and some borrowed clothes. She showered in the stall, a leftover locker room of sorts in a partially remodeled public restroom. People took turns guarding the door so she could have her privacy. I felt sadness for the woman, showering with horrible water pressure, in a shower that hadn’t been used for years, surrounded by old cold tile and strangers. All she wanted was her home, her things, her comfort. But she knew that if she returned to the home with her child, she’d be reported for putting her child at risk. I can imagine that she felt forced to strip and shower in this unwelcoming place.
I’m reminded of these images and thoughts as the Chris and Rihanna story splashes across the news nonstop. Personally, I no longer believe in secrets or lies. Domestic violence needs to be discussed. Yet I’m wondering if Rihanna is feeling hurt by strangers…pained and humiliated far beyond cuts, bruises, and blood. I wonder if it’s excruciating to hear other people talk about and around her… and at times, talking at, yes at, her with their advice. All of the superstars and the news reporters being the equivalent of folks at the break table giving their two cents or the helpers who are forcing her into a choice she maybe doesn’t want to make.
Many years after that day at the break table, I realized that the women were trying to be helpful. They were expressing their concern. And their thoughts that domestic violence is wrong. It is wrong. But the way they expressed it was more hurtful than anything I’ve ever experienced. And I sure hope Rihanna isn’t feeling that way now.
I wasn't going to add to any of the commentary but finally tonight, I'd heard so much that I wanted to scream. I wonder if she feels the same.
My wish is that Rihanna has someone who listens openly, honestly, and without agenda to what she needs and wants. That she’s not perceiving all the discussions, the debate, and spotlight as judgement. My hope is that she’s not being re-victimized.